Blog  /  Gear
Gear · Choosing

Standard MTB or E-Bike: how to decide which one suits you

At Seekers we rent both and adapt them to what each participant needs. This post gives you a way to choose: what changes with each bike, what a study says about effort, and what to ask yourself before writing to us.

By the Seekers team
Two standard mountain bikes leaning among arrayán trees beside a lake
E-Bikes lined up on a lake shore, with mountains behind
The core ideaChoose the bike you can ride on every day of the trip, and start the last day wanting to head out. The best one is whichever lets you do that, standard or electric.

A multi-day trip is decided with day four in mind

A one-day ride is judged by how you feel at the end. A multi-day trip is judged by how you start the morning of the fourth day, when your legs already have kilometers in them and the group is still the same. That’s why it’s worth choosing the bike for the whole week and not for the first climb.

At Seekers we rent both options, standard MTB and E-Bike, and adapt them to what each participant needs. This post helps you arrive at that conversation with clearer ideas.

What changes with each bike

Aspect
Standard MTB
E-Bike
Energy
All the pedaling comes from your legs.
Your legs plus a motor that adds to your effort according to the assist level you choose.
Climbs
You set the pace with how you feel that day.
The motor supports your pedaling and reduces the effort on climbs.
Weight
Lighter: easier to lift and maneuver.
Heavier because of the motor and battery. You notice it when pushing or lifting it.
Battery
None.
Limited range, which depends on assist level, elevation gain and weight. Charging has to be planned.
Descents
Less weight to brake and corner.
More weight on the way down: pay attention to braking and corners.
Group
Everyone brings their own pace.
Can help even out different paces within the same group.

General reference. The actual experience depends on the bike model, the terrain and the assist level.

Is the battery enough?

One practical question remains about the E-Bike: is the battery enough? Gabriel Ortega, a Seekers guide, answers it with figures from our own bikes. With assistance at level 1 on flat ground, the battery gives a safe 100 kilometers. On the routes we ride, covering 50 to 60 kilometers, we always finish with 25 to 30% of battery left.

We always charge the batteries the day before and, during the ride, if we stop at a restaurant or somewhere else, we take the chance to charge them. On certain routes we bring an electric generator; on the rest, everything is planned so it is not needed.

These are figures from our bikes, not for any E-Bike: real range depends on the assist level, the climbing and the weight, which is why charging is planned route by route.

We asked Gabi

How is E-Bike battery charging managed?

Gabriel Ortega, Seekers guide. The batteries are always charged the day before, and again at every stop. Video in Spanish, with Spanish subtitles.

What physiology says

A 2019 pilot study from Brigham Young University compared 33 experienced mountain bikers on the same short loop, once on a standard mountain bike and once on an E-Bike with pedal assist. On the E-Bike, average heart rate was about 10 beats per minute lower (145 versus 155). Even so, almost everyone stayed at a vigorous intensity: 29 of 33 on the E-Bike and 31 of 33 on the standard bike. They also finished the loop about twelve minutes faster.

Read carefully: the E-Bike reduces effort without removing it, and on that loop it was faster. The study had few participants, a single lap, one bike model and a group that already had experience, so it works as a clue and not as a rule for everyone.

What happens in your head

The effort you feel doesn’t always match what a heart rate monitor shows. A 2022 review of perceived exertion explains that this sensation is generated mostly from the command the brain sends to move the muscles and breathe, and that it isn’t a direct reading of the load your body is under. Two people with the same heart rate can experience the same stretch very differently. That’s why how you feel counts as much as the numbers.

Ryan and Deci’s self-determination theory proposes three needs that sustain motivation: feeling that you choose (autonomy), feeling that you can (competence) and feeling part of a group (relatedness). Applied to this decision, and this is our reading, not the authors’: choose the bike yourself, choose one that lets you feel capable on day four too, and think about which one lets you share the pace with the people you’re traveling with.

Csikszentmihalyi’s flow theory adds a useful question. According to that theory, we enjoy an activity more when challenge and skill are evenly matched: if the route overwhelms you, anxiety appears, and if it falls short, boredom does. It’s a theory, not a recipe. It helps put the decision another way: on which bike does the challenge sit at a point where you still have attention left to look at the landscape?

Participant in a white helmet beside a row of E-Bikes, with forest and mountain behind
Cyclist smiling on an orange E-Bike on a mountain road

Five questions to decide

How many days in a row have you ever ridden, and how did you arrive at the last one? It’s the best data point you have.
What do you want to take from the trip: the effort itself, or arriving with energy to enjoy the landscape and the group? Both answers are valid.
Who are you traveling with? If the group has different levels, the E-Bike can help everyone share the same pace.
Are you coming back after time off training, or do you have an injury or physical condition? Check with your doctor and tell us.
How do you feel about the weight of the bike and technique on descents? The E-Bike weighs more, and it’s worth considering.

When each one tends to fit

Standard MTB

You’ve been training and want all the progress to be yours.
You prefer a lighter bike with agile handling.
You’re interested in taking on the elevation on your own.

E-Bike

You’re coming back after time off or want to look after your energy for every day.
You’re traveling with people at a different level and want to share the pace.
You’d rather give more attention to the landscape and less to the effort of each climb.
You want to reach the longest climb with room to spare and not at the edge of your strength.

What each one costs to rent

Trip
Standard MTB
E-Bike
Cristo Redentor
USD 30 per day
USD 50 per day
Patagonia, 10 days
USD 280 for the whole tour
USD 480 for the whole tour
Patagonia, 7 days
USD 210 for the whole tour
USD 350 for the whole tour
Mendoza Premium
USD 180 for the whole tour, subject to availability
USD 300 for the whole tour, subject to availability
French Way
EUR 350 for the whole tour
EUR 400 for the whole tour
Portuguese Way
EUR 350 for the whole tour
EUR 400 for the whole tour

These are the values published on each trip page. They can change: confirm them on the trip page or on WhatsApp. Vergara-Pehuenche also has E-Bikes for rent: ask us for the options and the price.

How we handle it at Seekers

We rent both and adapt them to what each participant needs. Tell us how many days in a row you’ve ridden, what experience you have and what worries you, and we’ll work it out together before departure. On every trip you can bring your own bike; renting is one more option.

Once on the road, each day’s guide accompanies the group’s pace and keeps an eye on how each person is feeling.

Torn between the two?

Tell us how many days in a row you’ve ridden, how you feel on climbs and who you’re traveling with. We’ll reply on WhatsApp and work out together which one suits you.

Talk to the team Back to the blog